Why is Tesla stock falling over 3% today?

by Girls Rock Investing
Tesla factory with cars outside

Tesla stock TSLA fell over 3% on Friday as analysts questioned the benefit of the reported merger with SpaceX.

HSBC upgraded Tesla to Hold from Reduce and raised its price target to $359 from $157, citing speculation about a possible combination with Elon Musk’s space company.

However, the new target still implies downside of about 4% from Tesla’s previous closing price.

The potential merger has introduced a new dimension to Tesla’s investment outlook, although HSBC questioned whether combining the two businesses would deliver meaningful operational benefits in the near term.

HSBC sees control as key merger motivation

HSBC analyst Michael Tyndall said the strategic rationale for combining Tesla and SpaceX was not immediately clear, given their different end markets and limited near-term operational synergies.

Instead, the bank believes control could be the main motivation behind a potential transaction, particularly because Musk has greater voting power at SpaceX.

Musk owns approximately 39% of SpaceX, with around 70% of its voting rights.

At Tesla, his ownership and voting control stand at roughly 20%.

Tyndall believes SpaceX could emerge as the surviving entity in a merger, potentially allowing Musk to retain majority voting control of the combined company.

HSBC estimates that a 33% acquisition premium could value Tesla at $507 per share.

Combining that scenario with its fundamental valuation produces a weighted target price of $359, based on equal weighting between the two valuations.

A merger could also help SpaceX reduce future equity dilution.

The company faces substantial investment requirements related to artificial intelligence and data centres, which exceed Tesla’s capital needs.

However, HSBC highlighted regulatory risks, particularly in China, where Tesla has significant manufacturing operations and revenue exposure.

The bank maintained its Hold rating on SpaceX, with a $150 price target.

Gary Black warns of potential dilution

Investor Gary Black of The Future Fund LLC has also criticised the possibility of a SpaceX-Tesla merger, focusing on the potential consequences of a stock-for-stock transaction.

In a post on X, Black pointed to the recent deal between Lumentum Holdings and Marvell Technology as an example of the risks associated with using a company’s own shares to acquire another business.

Black said Marvell’s stock had fallen 45% in just over a month, reducing the 24% premium offered for Lumentum to a 41% discount relative to Lumentum’s share price before the announcement.

He attributed the decline to dilution in the acquiring company’s stock and argued that a similar outcome could follow if SpaceX used its shares as currency to acquire Tesla.

SpaceX deal could pressure Tesla shares

Black warned that Tesla investors could initially benefit from a short-term rise following a merger announcement, only to face selling pressure as investors seek to realise gains in SpaceX shares.

He suggested that a potential 24% premium for Tesla, paid in SpaceX stock, could lose value quickly if the transaction resulted in substantial dilution.

Using a Tesla share price of $374 and an implied SpaceX-based valuation of $464 after the premium, Black estimated that the value could fall by 25% within a month to around $280 per share.

His scenario assumes dilution of as much as 50% to SpaceX shares.

The comments reflect Black’s assessment of the potential risks rather than confirmed terms of a proposed transaction.

AI disclosure: AI tools assisted with research and drafting of this piece. An Invezz editor reviewed the facts, sources and wording before publication. Any opinions or analysis are Invezz’s, not those of an automated system.

The post Why is Tesla stock falling over 3% today? appeared first on Invezz

You may also like