Is Monetary Policy Tight? Spending Says Otherwise

by Girls Rock Investing

More than five years in, we still haven’t whipped inflation.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that consumer prices rose 0.4 percent in October, after climbing 0.6 percent in September. Don’t blame it all on gasoline: even omitting food and energy, prices rose 0.3 percent, the third straight month at that pace. That’s roughly 3.7 percent inflation per year. The Federal Reserve’s inflation target is 2 percent.

Everyone will wonder what this means for interest rates. The Fed held its target at 3.75-4 percent last month, and Fed watchers will spend the next few weeks arguing about what should be done at the December meeting. But interest rates are the wrong thing to watch.

If you want to know whether money is too loose, look at total spending in the economy, measured in current dollars. Economists call this aggregate demand. It grew at a 5.6 percent annual rate in the third quarter and 5.9 percent over the past year. Fed officials think the real economy can grow about 2 percent a year over the long run. Add 2 percent inflation, and total spending should be growing around 4 percent. We’re well above trend.

Excessive focus on interest rates can be misleading. An interest rate is a price: what borrowers pay savers to use their money. The Fed can nudge short-term rates for a while, which makes them a convenient tool. But a high rate doesn’t mean that money is tight. Lenders charge more when they expect inflation, so rates can rise precisely because policy has been too loose.

Ask Fed Chairman Kevin Warsh. The Fed raised rates in September, yet he told the press last month that he’s “unwilling and unable to call [financial conditions] tight.” Monetary policy doesn’t work by making loans cheap or dear. It works by changing how many dollars are chasing the economy’s supply of goods and services. The Fed should focus on something other than market interest rates.

That “something” else is total spending, measured by nominal (current-dollar) GDP is the right indicator of the stance of monetary policy. We need to compare what Americans actually spent with what they were expected to spend when wages were set, contracts signed, and investment plans made. When spending runs ahead of expectations, money is loose and prices get bid up. Economist Bryan Cutsinger tracks this in the Monetary Neutrality Report, published by the American Institute for Economic Research. His latest edition puts third-quarter spending at about $33 trillion. Professional forecasters had expected $32.6 trillion. That’s a gap of 1.2 percent, which the report classifies as “moderately loose.” Importantly, spending has exceeded its neutral level in every quarter since late 2020.

What should the Fed do? Tighten a little more. Its balance sheet has grown by more than $200 billion since last December. That’s the wrong direction. The Fed should start shrinking it again and tell the public it intends to keep contracting, mildly, until long-run inflation settles at 2 percent. That requires total spending growth to cool to 4 percent.

If Warsh’s Fed is credible, we should see the market’s inflation expectations adjust. Compare the yields on ordinary Treasury bonds with those on Treasury bonds that compensate holders for inflation: that’s the market’s forecast. As of Nov. 9, investors expected inflation to average about 2.25 percent over the next five years. That’s promising. But if that number starts climbing, the Fed must do more, and fast.

There’s been substantial disinflation since 2022, and it’s good the Fed has avoided major hits to employment or output. But there are limits to how much markets will tolerate. Even for a respected institution like the Fed, credibility requires careful maintenance. Inflation has run above the Fed’s target for close to six years. The longer that continues, the less the 2 percent promise sounds like a commitment and the more it sounds like cheap talk. Once workers and businesses stop believing it, they will factor higher inflation into wages, rents, and contracts. Inflationary expectations become “unanchored,” in the jargon of economists. At that point, regaining the public’s trust would be very costly.

The Fed needs to focus less on the price of credit and more on the value of the dollar. That’s the one thing it can control. For now, markets believe it is serious about price stability. It had better not give them a reason to doubt.

You may also like